21.2 FreeBSD-CURRENT vs. FreeBSD-STABLE

21.2.1.1 What Is FreeBSD-CURRENT?

FreeBSD-CURRENT is the latest working sources for FreeBSD. This includes work in progress, experimental changes, and transitional mechanisms that might or might not be present in the next official release of the software. While many FreeBSD developers compile the FreeBSD-CURRENT source code daily, there are periods of time when the sources are not buildable. These problems are resolved as expeditiously as possible, but whether or not FreeBSD-CURRENT brings disaster or greatly desired functionality can be a matter of which exact moment you grabbed the source code in!

21.2.1.2 Who Needs FreeBSD-CURRENT?

FreeBSD-CURRENT is made available for 3 primary interest groups:

1. Members of the FreeBSD group who are actively working on some part of the source tree and for whom keeping ``current'' is an absolute requirement.

2. Members of the FreeBSD group who are active testers, willing to spend time solving problems in order to ensure that FreeBSD-CURRENT remains as sane as possible. These are also people who wish to make topical suggestions on changes and the general direction of FreeBSD, and submit patches to implement them.

3. Those who merely wish to keep an eye on things, or to use the current sources for reference purposes (e.g. for reading, not running). These people also make the occasional comment or contribute code.

21.2.1.3 What Is FreeBSD-CURRENT Not?

1. A fast-track to getting pre-release bits because you heard there is some cool new feature in there and you want to be the first on your block to have it. Being the first on the block to get the new feature means that you're the first on the block to get the new bugs.

2. A quick way of getting bug fixes. Any given version of FreeBSD-CURRENT is just as likely to introduce new bugs as to fix existing ones.

3. In any way ``officially supported''. We do our best to help people genuinely in one of the 3 ``legitimate'' FreeBSD-CURRENT groups, but we simply do not have the time to provide tech support. This is not because we are mean and nasty people who do not like helping people out (we would not even be doing FreeBSD if we were). We simply cannot answer hundreds messages a day and work on FreeBSD! Given the choice between improving FreeBSD and answering lots of questions on experimental code, the developers opt for the former.

21.2.1.4 Using FreeBSD-CURRENT

1. Join the FreeBSD-CURRENT mailing list <freebsd-current@FreeBSD.org> and the FreeBSD CVS commit message mailing list <cvs-all@FreeBSD.org>. This is not just a good idea, it is essential. If you are not on the FreeBSD-CURRENT mailing list <freebsd-current@FreeBSD.org>, you will not see the comments that people are making about the current state of the system and thus will probably end up stumbling over a lot of problems that others have already found and solved. Even more importantly, you will miss out on important bulletins which may be critical to your system's continued health.

   The FreeBSD CVS commit message mailing list <cvs-all@FreeBSD.org> mailing list will allow you to see the commit log entry for each change as it is made along with any pertinent information on possible side-effects.

   To join these lists, send mail to <majordomo@FreeBSD.org> and specify the following in the body of your message:

       subscribe freebsd-current
       subscribe cvs-all
   

   Optionally, you can also say help and Majordomo will send you full help on how to subscribe and unsubscribe to the various other mailing lists we support.

2. Grab the sources from ftp.FreeBSD.org. You can do this in one of three ways:

   1. Use the cvsup program with this supfile. This is the most recommended method, since it allows you to grab the entire collection once and then only what has changed from then on. Many people run cvsup from cron and keep their sources up-to-date automatically. You have to customize the sample supfile above, and configure cvsup for your environment. If you want help doing this configuration, simply type:

          # pkg_add -f ftp://ftp.freebsd.org/pub/FreeBSD/ports/i386/packages/Latest/cvsupit.tgz
      

   2. Use ftp. The source tree for FreeBSD-CURRENT is always ``exported'' on: ftp://ftp.FreeBSD.org/pub/FreeBSD/FreeBSD-current/. Some of our FTP mirrors may also allow compressed/tarred grabbing of whole trees. e.g. you see:

          usr.bin/lex
      

      You can do the following to get the whole directory as a tar file:

          ftp> cd usr.bin
          ftp> get lex.tar
      

   3. Use the CTM facility. If you have very bad connectivity (high price connections or only email access) CTM is an option. However, it is a lot of hassle and can give you broken files. This leads to it being rarely used, which again increases the chance of it not working for fairly long periods of time. We recommend using CVSup for anybody with a 9600 bps modem or faster connection.

3. If you are grabbing the sources to run, and not just look at, then grab all of FreeBSD-CURRENT, not just selected portions. The reason for this is that various parts of the source depend on updates elsewhere, and trying to compile just a subset is almost guaranteed to get you into trouble.

   Before compiling FreeBSD-CURRENT, read the Makefile in /usr/src carefully. You should at least run a make world the first time through as part of the upgrading process. Reading the FreeBSD-CURRENT mailing list <freebsd-current@FreeBSD.org> will keep you up-to-date on other bootstrapping procedures that sometimes become necessary as we move towards the next release.

4. Be active! If you are running FreeBSD-CURRENT, we want to know what you have to say about it, especially if you have suggestions for enhancements or bug fixes. Suggestions with accompanying code are received most enthusiastically!

21.2.2.1 What Is FreeBSD-STABLE?

FreeBSD-STABLE is our development branch from which major releases are made. Changes go into this branch at a different pace, and with the general assumption that they have first gone into FreeBSD-CURRENT for testing. This is still a development branch, however, and this means that at any given time, the sources for FreeBSD-STABLE may or may not be suitable for any particular purpose. It is simply another engineering development track, not a resource for end-users.

21.2.2.2 Who Needs FreeBSD-STABLE?

If you are interested in tracking or contributing to the FreeBSD development process, especially as it relates to the next ``point'' release of FreeBSD, then you should consider following FreeBSD-STABLE.

While it is true that security fixes also go into the FreeBSD-STABLE branch, you do not need to track FreeBSD-STABLE to do this. Every security advisory for FreeBSD explains how to fix the problem for the releases it affects [1] , and tracking an entire development branch just for security reasons is likely to bring in a lot of unwanted changes as well.

Although we endeavor to ensure that the FreeBSD-STABLE branch compiles and runs at all times, this cannot be guaranteed. In addition, while code is developed in FreeBSD-CURRENT before including it in FreeBSD-STABLE, more people run FreeBSD-STABLE than FreeBSD-CURRENT, so it is inevitable that bugs and corner cases will sometimes be found in FreeBSD-STABLE that were not apparent in FreeBSD-CURRENT.

For these reasons, we do not recommend that you blindly track FreeBSD-STABLE, and it is particularly important that you do not update any production servers to FreeBSD-STABLE without first thoroughly testing the code in your development environment.

If you do not have the resources to do this then we recommend that you run the most recent release of FreeBSD, and use the binary update mechanism to move from release to release.

21.2.2.3 Using FreeBSD-STABLE

1. Join the FreeBSD-STABLE mailing list <freebsd-stable@FreeBSD.org>. This will keep you informed of build-dependencies that may appear in FreeBSD-STABLE or any other issues requiring special attention. Developers will also make announcements in this mailing list when they are contemplating some controversial fix or update, giving the users a chance to respond if they have any issues to raise concerning the proposed change.

   The FreeBSD CVS commit message mailing list <cvs-all@FreeBSD.org> mailing list will allow you to see the commit log entry for each change as it is made along with any pertinent information on possible side-effects.

   To join these lists, send mail to <majordomo@FreeBSD.org> and specify the following in the body of your message:

       subscribe freebsd-stable
       subscribe cvs-all
   

   Optionally, you can also say help and Majordomo will send you full help on how to subscribe and unsubscribe to the various other mailing lists we support.

2. If you are installing a new system and want it to be as stable as possible, you can simply grab the latest dated branch snapshot from ftp://releng4.FreeBSD.org/pub/FreeBSD/ and install it like any other release.

   If you are already running a previous release of FreeBSD and wish to upgrade via sources then you can easily do so from ftp.FreeBSD.org. This can be done in one of three ways:

   1. Use the cvsup program with this supfile. This is the most recommended method, since it allows you to grab the entire collection once and then only what has changed from then on. Many people run cvsup from cron to keep their sources up-to-date automatically. For a fairly easy interface to this, simply type:

          # pkg_add -f ftp://ftp.freebsd.org/pub/FreeBSD/ports/i386/packages/Latest/cvsupit.tgz
      

   2. Use ftp. The source tree for FreeBSD-STABLE is always ``exported'' on: ftp://ftp.FreeBSD.org/pub/FreeBSD/FreeBSD-stable/

      Some of our FTP mirrors may also allow compressed/tarred grabbing of whole trees. e.g. you see:

          usr.bin/lex
      

      You can do the following to get the whole directory for you as a tar file:

          ftp> cd usr.bin
          ftp> get lex.tar
      

   3. Use the CTM facility. If you do not have a fast and inexpensive connection to the Internet, this is the method you should consider using.

3. Essentially, if you need rapid on-demand access to the source and communications bandwidth is not a consideration, use cvsup or ftp. Otherwise, use CTM.

4. Before compiling FreeBSD-STABLE, read the Makefile in /usr/src carefully. You should at least run a make world the first time through as part of the upgrading process. Reading the FreeBSD-STABLE mailing list <freebsd-stable@FreeBSD.org> will keep you up-to-date on other bootstrapping procedures that sometimes become necessary as we move towards the next release.